The iconic Sunday dinner scenes in Blue Bloods have become a fan-favorite tradition, but filming them isn’t as effortless as they appear. With multiple cast members gathered around the table, shooting these heartfelt moments can take hours, requiring precise coordination and plenty of patience. One secret? The food is real, and the actors actually eat—though some opt for smaller bites to avoid overindulging after multiple takes.

Another behind-the-scenes tidbit is that Tom Selleck, who plays Frank Reagan, often sets the tone for these scenes, ensuring they maintain the warmth and authenticity that viewers love. The conversations may feel natural, but they’re carefully scripted, with some improvisation allowed to enhance realism. From continuity challenges to the pressure of delivering emotional dialogue while chewing, the Reagan family dinners are just as much a production challenge as they are a beloved part of the show.