Gary Cole’s darkest role came long before his time on NCIS, in his haunting portrayal of a convicted murderer in the forgotten 1995 TV movie The Brady Murder Case. In this chilling performance, Cole transformed into a cold-blooded killer, a departure from the typically more likable characters he often played. His portrayal was disturbingly convincing, capturing the eerie calmness and unsettling intensity of a man whose dark secrets slowly unravel. Despite being overshadowed by other projects at the time, this role remains one of Cole’s most unforgettable, showcasing his impressive range and ability to delve deep into the psyche of a murderer.

What makes this performance stand out even more is the subtlety with which Cole builds tension throughout the film. His character’s eerily detached demeanor contrasts sharply with the desperation of those around him, heightening the unsettling atmosphere. Though the film itself didn’t gain widespread recognition, Cole’s performance left an indelible mark, demonstrating that his true talent extended beyond the comedy and light drama he later became known for. In this haunting turn, Cole proved he could tackle complex, morally ambiguous roles with chilling precision, making it a standout in his career.